Jenna Vaughan-Mills
A
Just remember folks, Israel is committing genocide.

If you support its actions you are supporting the worst possible crime.
03:15 PM - Nov 18, 2023
Avatar
0
14
1
Sabine
A
In response to Jenna Vaughan-Mills.
There may be war crimes, but there is no genocide on part of Israel. Please be aware of the difference.

Jürgen Habermas, philosopher and moral authority:
"...the standards of judgement slip completely when genocidal intentions are attributed to Israel’s actions."
03:44 PM - Nov 18, 2023
1
0
Jenna Vaughan-Mills
A
In response to Sabine.
It is genocide, specifically the first three definitions in the Convention. Israel constantly shows intent through military activities as well as statements by politicians.

https://jewishcurrents.org...
06:47 PM - Nov 18, 2023
1
0
Sabine
A
In response to Jenna Vaughan-Mills.
Genocide requires the INTENT of eradicating a defined group of people, while Israel wants to deal with Hamas and puts up with collateral damage. Meaning there is no intent to kill not-Hamas Palestinians. Thus no genocide, but maybe a war crime due to a disproportionate exertion of military force
07:01 PM - Nov 18, 2023 (Edited)
3
1
Jenna Vaughan-Mills
A
Israel constantly demonstrates intent: mass destruction of housing rendering entire regions uninhabitable, targeting UN facilities and areas it says are "safe", denial of food, water and power, destruction of culture irrelevant to Hamas.

But by all means try arguing with _genocide expert_ Mr Segal.
In response to Sabine.
07:21 PM - Nov 18, 2023
1
0
Sabine
A
In response to Jenna Vaughan-Mills.
intent isn´t proven by taking at face value the utter BS some assorted individuals are uttering in Israeli politics. Intent means that genocide is the accepted and declared purpose throughout the chain of command, nothing less (this exactly made it so difficult to prove Russian intent in Ukraine)
07:39 PM - Nov 18, 2023
1
0
Jenna Vaughan-Mills
A
In response to Sabine.
Well funny, because that's exactly what we see from Israel's murderous genocidal attacks throughout Gaza!

Everything from obliterating thousands of children to destroying the parliament building to bulldozing Arafat's memorial, etc, etc.

But yeah, go argue with Raz Segal and tell me how it goes.
08:38 AM - Nov 19, 2023
1
0

 

{{ notificationModalContent }} {{ promptModalMessage }}