Monica Heilman
A
Confession: I received a grant rejection over a month ago and still haven't logged into the system to download reviewer comments.

I guess I should look at some point. But I just know my motivation will take a nosedive once I do.

#PhDchat #academicchatter #AcademicSpoutible
09:51 AM - May 25, 2023
Avatar Avatar
0
4
2
Sara FL Kirk
A
In response to Monica Heilman.
Have you looked yet? I remember being devastated with the reviewer feedback on my first submission to a journal that I didn't resubmit. They followed up and told me that such a mauling was normal so I signed up for a lifetime of it 🙃 #AcademicSpoutible #phdlife #academicchatter
08:06 AM - Jun 18, 2023
1
1
Monica Heilman
A
In response to Sara FL Kirk.
I did and this one actually has a happy ending! I'd already gotten 2 or 3 fellowship/grant rejections so I thought it'd be more of the same. But these turned out to be possibly the nicest reviews I've ever gotten 😭 They gave clear suggestions for improvement without shooting me down...
01:19 PM - Jun 18, 2023
2
2

 

{{ notificationModalContent }} {{ promptModalMessage }}