Marc
A
thread 1/3
SCOTUS Chief Justice John Roberts should heed the advice of DC Circuit Justice John Roberts (himself, from 20 years ago) in PDK Laboratories v. DEA: "If it is not necessary to decide more, it is necessary not to decide more."
09:55 AM - Apr 30, 2024
Avatar Avatar Avatar
0
1
10
Marc
A
thread 2/3
There's no need for the Supreme Court to wade into a 'doom loop' of hypotheticals about the extent of immunity tied to presidential powers. Instead, the focus should sharply remain on whether Trump has immunity from the charges as presented.
09:55 AM - Apr 30, 2024
0
6
Marc
A
thread 3/3
This focused approach ensures the case is resolved based on its facts, avoiding the trap of broader speculative legal debates unrelated to the case before the Court.
09:55 AM - Apr 30, 2024
0
3
Robin Zimmermann
A
In response to Marc.
Yes. What the Supreme Court is now doing is not calling balls and strikes. They are about to make law that doesn’t need to be made.

Isn’t that judicial activism?
09:58 AM - Apr 30, 2024
0
2

 

{{ notificationModalContent }} {{ promptModalMessage }}