Mark Rubin
A
Does it replicate?

New review article surveyed replication studies (do it again, see if it works again) published between 2018-2019. The overall replication rate was 53.7%, but this varied markedly between fields:

Cobey et al. (2023): https://doi.org/10.7554/eL...

#academicchatter
08:04 PM - Jun 26, 2023
Avatar Avatar Avatar
0
4
5
Jess Martin
A
In response to Mark Rubin.
Psychology is way below average. Wonder why.
02:15 AM - Jun 27, 2023
1
1
Mark Rubin
A
In response to Jess Martin.
Yes, pretty low. The authors did note:

"Low rates in psychology were driven by a single document reporting 37 studies that failed to report outcomes. When this document was removed, rates improved to 51.0% in this discipline.”
02:21 AM - Jun 27, 2023
1
1
Jess Martin
A
In response to Mark Rubin.
Why was that document included in the first place? Cited too much? Definitely skewed the average with that one!
02:23 AM - Jun 27, 2023
1
0
Mark Rubin
A
I think they were just following their review protocol. But good that they spotted it wa skewing the results because it makes a huge difference!
In response to Jess Martin.
02:36 AM - Jun 27, 2023
0
1

 

{{ notificationModalContent }} {{ promptModalMessage }}